This post is co-authored by Fernando Hoces de la Guardia, BITSS postdoctoral scholar, along with Sean Grant (Associate Behavioral and Social Scientist at RAND) and BITSS Faculty Director Ted Miguel. It is cross-posted with the CEGA Blog. The Royal Society’s motto, “Take nobody’s word for it,” reflects a key principle of scientific…
Welcome to the BITSS Blog
Registered Reports: Piloting a Pre-Results Review Process at the Journal of Development Economics
This post, written by Andy Foster, Dean Karlan, and CEGA Faculty Director Ted Miguel, was originally published on the World Bank’s Development Impact blog. It can also be found on the CEGA blog. The world is a messy place. What happens when the results of an empirical study are mushy or inconsistent…
Open Science and a Culture of Health: You Two Should Talk
Guest post by Sean Grant and Kathryn Bouskill (RAND Corporation) The Open Science movement aims to advance scientific progress by making research more open and accessible. The Culture of Health movement aims to advance collective well-being by making health a shared value and priority among all policy sectors, not just healthcare. Proponents…
2017 Annual Meeting Showcases Innovations for Transparent and Reproducible Science
By: Kelsey Mulcahy, BITSS Program Manager The 2017 Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences (BITSS) moved beyond the credibility crisis in social science research to discuss potential solutions. The two-day event featured a workshop, two panel discussions, an award ceremony for the 2017 Leamer-Rosenthal Prize Recipients,…
Navigating the Garden of Forking Paths
Guest post by Kweku Opoku-Agyemang (Center for Effective Global Action, Cornell Tech, and International Growth Centre) Improving ethical and transparency standards within and across the social and behavioral science professions appears to be more of a journey than a destination. Thankfully, this is a voyage that has an ever-growing number of travelers.…
Reflections from three years of Leamer-Rosenthal… and considerations for the future of open social science!
“I didn’t do my work for money or prizes – but for the excitement of discovery” – Edmund Phelps (Economist) BITSS recently announced the 2017 Leamer-Rosenthal Prize Recipients. The eight recipients, as well as the larger pool of nominees, are part of a growing movement in social science to practice better science,…
Diary of a Research Transparency Postdoc: South America Tour
Fernando Hoces de la Guardia – BITSS Postdoctoral Scholar I joined BITSS in September as its first postdoc and was excited to hit the ground running with a series of events to promote research transparency in Latin America. Through partnerships with local universities, we managed to organize back-to-back seminars in Chile, Peru…
The Power of Bias in Economics Research
Tom Stanley, friend of BITSS and one of the leaders of the Meta-Analysis of Economics Research Network (MAER-Net), recently published a paper in The Economic Journal with John Ioannidis and Chris Doucouliagos on statistical power in economics research that should be of interest to the BITSS network. From Tom: “The power of…
Recipients of 2017 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science
The Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences (BITSS) awards eight prizes to researchers and educators demonstrating values and practices of openness and transparency in research. BERKELEY, CA (Thursday, October 12, 2017) – The open science community has grown rapidly in recent years, partly in response to a series of newsworthy…
Public Data that Isn’t (or Wasn’t) Public
–Guest Post: Justin Gallagher, Assistant Professor of Economics, Case Western Reserve University I recently completed a coauthored working paper, together with Paul J. Fisher, that examines whether electronic monitoring via red light traffic cameras leads to fewer vehicle accidents and injuries. As part of the project, we…
Review of Stata’s dyndoc
Guest post: Tomas Dvorak is a Professor of Economics at Union College and a former Project TIER fellow. This is a repost. The original post can be found here. As a huge fan of Stata I was super-excited about dynamic markdown documents newly available in the latest Stata 15 release. I played with…
Kicking off a new partnership with The Choice Lab at the 68° North Conference
Jennifer Sturdy–BITSS Program Advisor Science, my lad, is made up of mistakes, but they are mistakes which it is useful to make, because they lead little by little to the truth. It seems fitting that I read a book which references this Jules Verne quote just before our BITSS panel on research…
Some SSMART reflections on who is doing research on transparency and doing that research transparently!
BITSS is delighted with the steady release of the results from our SSMART-funded research portfolio, and with the incredible response to some of the projects. It goes without saying that SSMART aimed to fund research on topics that would help fuel improved transparency and reproducibility in the social sciences – this meant…
It Depends…(and not on the weather)
A read out on key questions from Day 2 of our Research Transparency and Reproducibility Workshop (RT2) in Berkeley, California. Well, Day 1 of RT2 was foggy – but Day 2 brought the Northern California rain. If you participated in Day 2, or visited our OSF page to follow along on your…
Trying to clear the fog
We had a lovely, foggy morning start to our Research Transparency and Reproducibility Training (RT2) here in Berkeley yesterday, and we have already had the opportunity to enjoy some great conversations with participants and faculty alike. One early suggestion brought to us by Arnaud Vaganay was the need to first frame what…
Announcing Open Enrollment for the BITSS MOOC: Transparent and Open Social Science Research
Most of you probably noticed that 2015 marked a turning point for BITSS. It was the year we launched our Social Science Meta-Analysis and Research Transparency (SSMART) Grant Program, the Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science, and our new website. It was also the year we started focusing on two main objectives…
Opening the ‘black box’: the need for fidelity and process evaluations of behaviour change interventions
Guest Post: Elaine Toomey, Health Behaviour Change Research Group, National University of Ireland, Galway Sometimes the journey is just as, if not more, important than the destination. A motivational quote that perhaps graces one too many t-shirts of travellers seeking to ‘find themselves’, it is never more appropriate than when it comes…
Questions from Our Latest Workshop
Garret Christensen–BITSS Project Scientist I’m in Barcelona, where I delivered a reproducibility workshop and am attending the International Meeting on Experimental and Behavioral Social Sciences (IMEBESS). The materials from the workshop are available on Github, as always. I got several good questions from the workshop participants, some methodological, some software, and I…
Reproducibility of Research: Issues and Proposed Remedies – A Sackler Colloquium Reflection
Guest post: Cynthia M. Kroeger, Postdoctoral Fellow, Nutrition Obesity Research Center, University of Alabama at Birmingham From March 8-10, 2017, I had the honor of joining scientific researchers, publishers, journalists, entrepreneurs, and funders from all over the world to discuss Reproducibility of Research: Issues and Proposed Remedies. This Sackler colloquium of the…
Reflections from BITSS’s First Workshop in South Asia
By BITSS Program Manager Kelsey Mulcahy You’ve probably noticed the growing interest in research transparency and reproducibility issues and training – conversations with your colleagues, increasing numbers of high-profile panels – and of course, a number of BITSS workshops this Spring from UC Merced, California to Cuernavaca, Mexico to Delhi, India. We…
BITSS Preprints launches today!
Launching BITSS Preprints, an interdisciplinary archive of articles focused on improving research transparency and reproducibility. During the BITSS Annual Meeting in December 2016, several researchers approached us about launching a new Working Paper series. The reason was simple – a common challenge faced by leaders and soon-to-be-leaders in the research transparency and…
Accepting Nominations for the 2017 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science
It’s that time of the year again! We’re excited to announce a third round of Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science! Since the inaugural round two years ago, BITSS has awarded 17 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science in an effort to reward social scientists who do the hard and often unrecognized…
Announcing 8 New Catalyst Training Grants!
The Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences (BITSS) is pleased to announce the recipients of our first round of competitively selected Catalyst grants![1] Over the next year, 12 BITSS Catalysts will carry out 8 projects in 10 countries, holding conferences, workshops, and summer schools, and developing curriculum for both traditional…
Research Transparency Workshops in Cameroon, South Africa, and the UK
Guest post: Elise Wang Sonne, United Nations University-MERIT, Netherlands 2016 was definitely a very exciting year for me as a BITSS Catalyst, as I organized three transparency and reproducibility workshops in Sub-Saharan Africa and Europe. The transparency journey ended with my speech during the 2016 OpenCon Conference on a plenary panel on…
R for Stata Users
Garret Christensen —BITSS Project Scientist For whatever reason, economists use a lot of Stata. It does what we want to do (data cleaning, regression analysis, data visualization) well, and the $1,000 fees we pay every other version or so doesn’t seem to have stopped its widespread adoption. But is that changing, and…
Accepting proposals for a third round of SSMART Grants!
BITSS is launching the third round of our Social Science Meta-Analysis and Research Transparency (SSMART) Grants – this time with a focus on research led by or partnered with researchers in the Global South. The SSMART grant initiative seeks to support and encourage important meta-research in the social sciences in order to…
CEGA and the African School of Economics collaborate at the Summer Institute for Economics Research
This is a reblog from the EASST Collaborative, written by former EASST Visting Fellow Constantine Manda. See the original post here. From December 12-17 2016, the African School of Economics (ASE) hosted its annual Summer Institute for Economic Research (SIER) in Contonou, Benin. Over the course of the week, over 100 participants were able…
Our 2017 ASSA Session
Garret Christensen –BITSS Project Scientist BITSS organized a session on meta-analysis and reproducibility in economics for the recent Allied Social Sciences Associations (ASSA, but better known as the AEAs, the largest annual economics conference and job market for PhD economists) in Chicago. Chicago, as much of the country, was in the midst…
StatTag: New Tool for Reproducible Research
Guest Post: Richard Ball, Associate Professor of Economics, Haverford College & Director, Project TIER R Markdown is a great tool. It ensures reproducibility by incorporating both text and chunks of R code in a single source file that can be rendered into a formatted report, with results generated by the R code…
Goldilocks RCTs
SSMART grant recipients Fiona Burlig, Louis Preonas, and Matt Woerman have released a working paper based on their work on power calculations. With permission we’re reposting Fiona Burlig’s blog post here in its entirety. Check out the paper, or download the Stata code and see the pre-registration on the OSF. You can…
Winners of the 2016 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science
The Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences awards ten prizes this year to researchers working to forward the values of openness and transparency in research. BERKELEY, CA (Thursday, December 15, 2016) – Since its inception as an initiative within the Center for Effective Global Action (CEGA) in 2012, the Berkeley…
BITSS Annual Meeting Morning Software Workshop Details
Garret Christensen–BITSS Project Scientist If you’re coming to the Annual Meeting this Thursday, you may be curious what exactly we’re doing during the optional training workshop Thursday morning. I’ll give a brief overview of software tools that can help with reproducible workflow, and then we’ll spend most of the time demonstrating dynamic…
Announcing two of nine winners of the 2016 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science: Michèle Nuijten and Sacha Epskamp!
If you’re anything like us here at the Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences (BITSS), you’ve been on the lookout for the most notable innovators in research transparency and reproducibility. That’s why we were thrilled to receive 44 nominations for researchers and educators from 18 disciplines and sub-disciplines and 12…
BITSS issues Call for Projects to Current Catalysts
BITSS began almost four years ago as a small, but strong grassroots movement to change how social science is conducted to be more transparent and reproducible. After years of events, trainings, and publications, BITSS launched its Catalyst Program last November to harness its growing, grassroots network of social scientists dedicated to changing…
BITSS in the APS Observer | Open Science Training in Kenya
BITSS Director Jen Sturdy and Catalyst Stephanie Wykstra wrote a blog post about an open science workshop co-hosted by BITSS and IPA in Kenya earlier this year. In it, they situate the workshop within the larger transparency movement and put forth some important questions for researchers to consider as they construct their…
Panel on Reproducible Journalism
–Garret Christensen, BITSS Project Scientist Last month a colleague of mine from the Berkeley Institute for Data Science (BIDS), John Bohannon, and I organized a panel discussion on the subject of reproducible journalism for Stanford’s Computation + Journalism Symposium. John is a contributing correspondent for Science, but he’s been visiting BIDS for…
Berkeley Initiative Scales up Research Transparency and Reproducibility Trainings
Annual trainings will bring together researchers from across the social sciences to promote transparency and reproducibility in social science research Berkeley, Calif – Sept. 30, 2016 – To scale up and institutionalize open science trainings, the Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences (BITSS) received a National Institutes of Health (NIH) award…
Accepting Nominations for the 2016 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science
In an effort to reward social scientists who do the hard work of advancing practices of transparency and the use of reproducible methods in research, BITSS is accepting nominations for the 2016 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science. BITSS will award $10,000 to $15,000 to faculty who have incorporated research transparency methods…
Research Transparency in Social Sciences Landed in Francophone Africa
Guest Post: Zacharie Tsala Dimbuene, University of Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of the Congo Everything started in March 2016, when I attended a workshop in Athi River (Nairobi, Kenya) organized by Berkeley Initiative for Transparency in the Social Sciences about “Research Transparency in Social Sciences” (RTSS, hereafter). What caught my attention first is…
Upcoming Opportunities: Call for Papers x2, Nominations x1
We’ve got three big opportunities coming up. Two are new announcements, and one is a reminder. NEW: Annual Meeting Call for Papers– The 5th BITSS Annual Meeting will be in Berkeley December 15-16. This is our annual forum to highlight advances in the field of transparency and reproducibility across the social sciences.…
Open Source Interfaces with the Programmable Web Facilitate Replications of Big Data Analyses in Social Science Research
Guest Post: Ulrich Matter and Alois Stutzer, University of Basel The replicability of social science research is becoming more demanding in the age of big data. First, researchers aiming to replicate a study based on massive data face substantial computational costs. Second, and probably more challenging, they are often confronted with “highly…
An Inside Perspective of a Registered Replication Report (RRR)
Irene Cheung, Assistant Professor of Psychology at Western University – Huron Lorne Campbell, Professor of Social Psychology at Western University Etienne LeBel, BITSS Project Scientist In the spring of 2014 we (i.e., Irene Cheung, Lorne Campbell and Etienne LeBel) decided to submit a proposal to Perspectives on Psychological Science for a Registered Replication Report…
Research Transparency Enhances Evidence Credibility in East Africa
EASST fellow Saint Kizito Omala, Lecturer at Makerere University and Senior Examinations Officer at the Uganda National Examinations Board. Technical details, which are often hidden, are what guarantee the credibility of published scientific work. In this regard, Research Transparency (RT) is a primer! To lay bare all retraceable procedures and facts that…
UC Berkeley and California Government Data Sharing Forum
BITSS and Berkeley Opportunity Lab When a representative from the California Judicial Council attended the BITSS Annual Meeting last December, she asked the group an interesting question – if we want to be more transparent and share data, how can we do so in a responsible way that limits risk to those…
Save the Dates: Upcoming BITSS Events
If you’re interested in joining BITSS and others as a presenter at a conference session on transparency, replication, and reproducibility at the Institute for New Economic Thinkings’ Young Scholars Initiative (YSI) Plenary in Budapest Oct 19-22, please contact Garret. We’re hoping to submit a session proposal by the end of July. The…
Mid-Summer Recap
Garret Christensen–BITSS Project Scientist BITSS and I have been busy lately. Here’s a quick rundown: If you want to learn or teach reproducible programming, Software Carpentry is one of the best organizations out there–check out their lesson materials and see if they’re offering a workshop near you. I got hooked up with…
Psychology Open Science Progress Report
Etienne LeBel–BITSS Project Scientist My name is Etienne LeBel and I’m a new Project Scientist at BITSS. My background is in social psychology (areas: racial biases/stereotypes, self, & attitudes/persuasion), though most of my recent work involves meta-scientific contributions in the emerging open science and replication movement in psychology. My primary role at…
You get a grant, you get a grant, you get a grant.
We don’t quite have Oprah money, but we did give some very cool stuff away recently. By that I mean we are proud to officially announce our 2016 SSMART grant award winners. SSMART stands for “Social Science Meta-Analysis and Research Transparency” and we try to fund three types of research projects: Develop…
Out of the file drawer: Tips on prepping data for publication
Guest post: Julia Clark, Graduate Student Researcher, Policy Design and Evaluation Lab; PhD student in the Department of Political Science, UCSD Publishing data and code is crucial to ensuring that social science research is transparent and reproducible. But researchers are busy people. Once a manuscript is accepted, the task…
2016 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science
We have officially announced the 2016 Leamer-Rosenthal Prizes for Open Social Science. This is a series of cash awards for young researchers conducting transparent and reproducible social science, and for teachers who have been promoting reproducibility. You can read more and download the official application instructions from the main L-R Prizes page.…